Goodale farms is located on the North Fork of Long Island. We are the ONLY dairy farm that bottles our own milk from our own cows and goats. We have been farming the East End since the 1850's and have recently added our dairy operation.

We have been following the same practices handed down for 5 generation, we do not use pesticides, insecticides, growth hormones of any kind. We use our animals' manure as much as possible and we consider ourselves a fully self sustained operation. Our pigs are fed the whey that is a by product of our cheese process, our goats and cows eat excess produce for the fields, our bees pollinate our crops, our free range chicken help break up our manure piles and add vital nutrients to the soil. Our cows are grass fed and treated humanely. We believe in living the way our ancestors lived 100 years ago. We are striving to get back to that way of life.

Listing last updated on Jan 12, 2012

Farm tours and cheesemaking classes are available. We produce a full line of seasonal fruits and vegetables. Our dairy products consist of butter, cream cheese, yogurt, eggs, glass bottled milk, goat cheese, cow cheese.

Schedule and Location:

Shelter Island
Sag Harbor
6th Ave & Carmine St. NYC

Schedule and Location:

Our stand is open year round.

Latest Reviews

The website is no longer up and when I called the number listed the guy said I have the wrong number.

See All Reviews

Products and Crops


Upload a Photo

Drag and drop an image file here or click to browse your computer.

Photo Upload Requirements

  • File size limit of 2 MB per image.
  • Recommended image resolution is 800x600 to 1024x768 pixels.
  • Main profile images will be resized to a width of 250 px.

Cancel OK

Delete this Photo?

Warning: This cannot be undone, once deleted this image will be gone from your gallery.

Cancel OK

Set as Profile Photo

Use this photo as your main profile image?

Cancel OK

Photo Caption

Cancel OK