The chickens are smaller then you would get from the grocery store (I assume due to the way they are raised), but they are very flavorful when cooked and aren't salty or tasteless at all, something that I do find with grocery store chickens.
The pork chops are the best I've ever had the beef is also top-notch.
The share sizes are larger than I expected and, while not a bargain, are very good value for the amount you get. Depending on how many people eat the share, you may need to supplement on the eggs but unless you eat meat every night you should need minimal outside meat buying for 2 adults.
If you are considering a meat CSA, I highly recommend Cedar Valley. Beth and Jody are very accommodating and helpful and the food is great