For starters we purchased some more expensive "June BBQ Broilers". Given that I hadn't worked with them before, I sent Aaron an email 3 weeks before the expected date to find out whether they were delivering them to us or if there was a common pick-up location in Madison. He replied that he'd be sending out an email with details. I didn't hear anything from him until September and didn't receive my early broilers.
While he did replace them with a later batch of broilers, they weren't any larger so in a sense we paid $0.25 more per pound for nothing. Additionally the turkey we purchased was 10lbs instead of the 14 pounds we paid. At $3.50/lb, it adds up.
On the plus side, their meat was extremely high quality, well cleaned, and very tasty.
All said and done, I'm split as to whether I would order again.